Memory cannot be outsourced
A couple of weeks ago, I wrote a post arguing that the ‘traditional’ understanding of a hierarchical, teacher-centric classroom has not existed in English schools since at least the 1960s. In the comments thread, I am trying to list examples of people claiming that this model of teaching still does exist (normally in the context of them saying that it should be abolished). Andrew Old has been particularly diligent in finding examples. Thank you Andrew.
In this post, I want to do something similar. Here, I want to list examples of people claiming that we don’t need to learn facts because we have the internet. I mean things like this:
What matters today is how to process and manipulate knowledge, rather than absorbing and memorising facts from within a narrow specialism…Facts learned at school become irrelevant to most of life’s challenges since the internet makes knowledge universal and immediately accessible.
Why teach them about the Battle of Hastings when they have got Google?
We are no longer in an age where a substantial ‘fact bank’ in our heads is required.
This is another example of a completely false idea which nevertheless seems to be extremely pervasive. What is so frustrating about this one is that the hard evidence about why we need to memorise facts is solid and well-documented, but not nearly so well-known. Here is what I think is the best article about this available on the internet – E.D. Hirsch’s You Can Always Look It Up…Or Can You? I have also written about it here, here and here.
0 responses to “Memory cannot be outsourced”
- What is Mastery? The good, the bad, the ugly May 7, 2019
- What the marathon teaches you about education April 27, 2019
- English Mastery: Writing an evidence-based curriculum April 18, 2019
- My top 10 education books of 2018 December 15, 2018
- Global Education and Skills Forum 2018 March 20, 2018
- Research Ed 2017 September 10, 2017
- Feedback and English mocks August 16, 2017
- Workload and English mocks July 22, 2017
- Life after Levels: Five years on June 11, 2017
- Five ways you can make the primary writing moderation process less stressful June 4, 2017